Negligence by Design: The True Cause of Pakistan’s Recurrent Floods

Pakistan’s recurrent and devastating floods, particularly those impacting the provinces of Punjab and Sindh, are often framed as a natural disaster caused by intense monsoon rains. While climate change and torrential downpours are significant factors, a closer examination reveals that these catastrophes are largely a man-made crisis, a direct result of decades of poor governance, institutional failure, and a lack of foresight. The current flooding, much like previous events, exposes a deep-seated vulnerability that has been exacerbated by political negligence, failed infrastructure policies, and rampant encroachment.

The Failure of Flood Management and Infrastructure

One of the most critical failures lies in Pakistan’s approach to water management and infrastructure. The nation has a chronic shortage of large dams and water reservoirs, which are essential for controlling floodwaters during the monsoon season.  Instead of building new storage capacity, successive governments have been bogged down by political disputes and a lack of consensus on key projects like the Kalabagh Dam. Critics argue that without new mega-dams, the country remains at the mercy of nature’s fury, as existing structures like the Mangla and Tarbela dams are insufficient to manage the extraordinary volume of water from glacial melt and extreme rainfall events.

Even the existing infrastructure has suffered from a lack of maintenance and corruption. Reports have highlighted the disastrous state of flood embankments, which are often poorly maintained and unable to withstand the pressure of rising river levels. The 2022 floods saw the catastrophic failure of several dams in Balochistan, a tragedy directly linked to the use of substandard construction materials and widespread corruption. This neglect demonstrates a systemic problem: the very systems designed to protect citizens are failing due to institutional incompetence and financial mismanagement.

The Encroachment Catastrophe

The problem is compounded by a culture of unchecked encroachment on riverbeds, floodplains, and natural waterways. In both Punjab and Sindh, rivers and their tributaries have been choked by illegal settlements, commercial properties, and even residential societies. These encroachments, often carried out with the tacit approval of corrupt officials, obstruct the natural flow of water, significantly reducing the carrying capacity of rivers. When the water swells from monsoon rains, it has nowhere to go but into these illegally occupied areas, turning a manageable flood into a widespread disaster.

Cities like Lahore, Karachi, and Sialkot have also fallen victim to urban flooding due to similar issues. Stormwater drains and nullahs (drainage channels) have been encroached upon or clogged with solid waste, rendering them useless. The result is a cycle of destruction where a few hours of heavy rain can bring a major city to a standstill, with streets turning into rivers and homes being submerged. A 2020 report from the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) rightly stated that these problems are “inherently political,” as powerful political parties and figures often use building permits to fuel their patronage networks, disregarding the risks.

The Role of Monsoon Rains, and India

While internal governance issues are the primary drivers of the floods’ severity, the natural factors cannot be ignored. Climate change has intensified the monsoon season, leading to more erratic and heavier rainfall across South Asia. Pakistan has been experiencing “super floods,” with rainfall volumes far exceeding historical averages. This is not just a Pakistani problem; neighboring India and Bangladesh are also grappling with the same climate-driven phenomena.

The cross-border aspect of the floods, particularly with India, adds another layer of complexity. The Indus Waters Treaty of 1960 governs the distribution of shared river resources between the two nations. However, in times of high-intensity monsoon rains, India’s management of its upstream dams can have a direct and severe impact on Pakistan. As rivers like the Sutlej, Ravi, and Chenab swell from rainfall in Indian-administered regions, India releases excess water from its overflowing dams. While Indian officials have stated these releases are made on “humanitarian grounds” with prior warnings, the sheer volume of water significantly exacerbates the flooding situation in downstream Pakistan, particularly in Punjab. This diplomatic tension, combined with the suspension of a key water-sharing mechanism, highlights the fragility of the relationship and the need for greater regional cooperation in the face of a shared climate threat.

In conclusion, the floods in Punjab and Sindh are a tragic reflection of a governance crisis. The lack of a long-term vision for water management, the failure to build new dams and the rampant encroachment on riverine areas has created a man-made catastrophe. While the unpredictable nature of monsoon rains and India’s upstream water releases are contributing factors, the sheer scale of the disaster is a consequence of Pakistan’s own inaction and political neglect. The path forward requires a fundamental shift from reactive, post-disaster relief to a proactive, long-term strategy of building climate-resilient infrastructure and enforcing strict environmental laws. Without this change, the annual floods will continue to be a grim and avoidable ritual.

You May Like To Read: Punjab Floods Worsen: Government Issues High Alert as Rivers Swell to “Exceptionally High” Levels